Welcome to the Stony Point Book Blog!
This is a forum for Stony Point students and staff to discuss popular books.
To post to this site, sign up for an account in the library.
__________
Blog Guidelines:
Please remember that this is a school related site and all posts must be school appropriate. This site will be monitored. Any post deemed inappropriate will be deleted immediately and the poster may be blocked.
I am totally team Edward. I like him better and seems to have it more together then Jacob (but he has had a few more years worth of practice). I think the addiction that Bella has is too deep to be left alone now. If Edward left, I foresee suicide.
Team Jacob. Edward is too...perfect. I dunno. I just was really wanting him to get Bella, but them I remembered she bugs the hell out of me BUT I still felt bad for him. If I had to pick between the two I would so pick Jacob
I, too, think that Bella wouldn't survive if she lost Edward. At this point, I'm not sure who's better for her, but it seems inevitable that she will become a Vamp (b/c the Volturi), so I think I have to go Team Edward...
Of course everyone says Edward...but if it were you in Bella's position, would you really decide to become a vampire so that you could stay with Edward?...i mean...really.
I'm betting that most people wouldn't choose vampirism if they had a perfectly good Native American werewolf boy waiting in the backgroud.
unfortunately, I agree that Bella can't survive without Edward. I think she's convinced herself of it and now can't possibly convince herself otherwise. She has to become a Vampire anyway now b/c of the Volturi, and how can a vampire marry a wearwolf? I think they both have they're pros and cons, and Jacob would be better for her if i had more practice controlling himself. But it really doesn't matter because she's chosen Edward and Vampireism and doesn't believe she can live with out Edward.
Completely and totally Team Jacob. Bella would be safer with Jacob anyway. One slip up of Bella's part and Edward could end up killing her for sure. He's already caused her so much pain by leaving in the second book. Also if you think about the family arrangements, Bella would have an easier time staying with Jacob because her father, Charlie, has known him for a long time. Edward is new to the scene and I'm sure her father wouldn't like the fact that she is going away and not going to return. Jacob is definately better fit for Bella.
Stephanie Meyer said that her next book will be the final in the series. Looking at it from the writer's perspective, what do you think she will do? I think she will choose Jacob, but Edward fans will be heartbroker (myself included). What do yall think? PS The book comes out soon (Aug), get your copy reserved today!
9 comments:
I am totally team Edward. I like him better and seems to have it more together then Jacob (but he has had a few more years worth of practice). I think the addiction that Bella has is too deep to be left alone now. If Edward left, I foresee suicide.
only read the first one so far hopeing to get the rest for x-mas
but i cant see any one being more perfect for Bella than Edward
Team Jacob. Edward is too...perfect. I dunno. I just was really wanting him to get Bella, but them I remembered she bugs the hell out of me BUT I still felt bad for him. If I had to pick between the two I would so pick Jacob
I, too, think that Bella wouldn't survive if she lost Edward. At this point, I'm not sure who's better for her, but it seems inevitable that she will become a Vamp (b/c the Volturi), so I think I have to go Team Edward...
Of course everyone says Edward...but if it were you in Bella's position, would you really decide to become a vampire so that you could stay with Edward?...i mean...really.
I'm betting that most people wouldn't choose vampirism if they had a perfectly good Native American werewolf boy waiting in the backgroud.
unfortunately, I agree that Bella can't survive without Edward. I think she's convinced herself of it and now can't possibly convince herself otherwise. She has to become a Vampire anyway now b/c of the Volturi, and how can a vampire marry a wearwolf? I think they both have they're pros and cons, and Jacob would be better for her if i had more practice controlling himself. But it really doesn't matter because she's chosen Edward and Vampireism and doesn't believe she can live with out Edward.
Completely and totally Team Jacob. Bella would be safer with Jacob anyway. One slip up of Bella's part and Edward could end up killing her for sure. He's already caused her so much pain by leaving in the second book. Also if you think about the family arrangements, Bella would have an easier time staying with Jacob because her father, Charlie, has known him for a long time. Edward is new to the scene and I'm sure her father wouldn't like the fact that she is going away and not going to return. Jacob is definately better fit for Bella.
Stephanie Meyer said that her next book will be the final in the series. Looking at it from the writer's perspective, what do you think she will do? I think she will choose Jacob, but Edward fans will be heartbroker (myself included). What do yall think? PS The book comes out soon (Aug), get your copy reserved today!
Post a Comment